US
Sign in Get alerts

Comparisons

Switch 2 GameCube controller vs Pro Controller for classics and Smash

Switch 2 GameCube controller ($69.99) vs Pro Controller ($89.99): which is better for GameCube classics, Smash and modern games, and what each one lacks.

Get the GameCube controller if you mostly play GameCube Nintendo Classics or Smash. Get the Pro Controller for everything else. At the Nintendo Store on Nov 17, 2026, the GameCube pad was $69.99 and the Pro Controller $89.99, both in stock. The GameCube pad lacks a minus button, stick clicks and full HD Rumble.

Side-by-side table, Nintendo Store, Nov 17, 2026: GameCube controller for Switch 2 $69.99, in stock, needs paid Nintendo Switch Online to buy, rumble only in some games, no minus button or stick clicks, no back buttons, no amiibo or audio jack listed; Switch 2 Pro Controller $89.99, in stock, no membership needed, HD Rumble 2, remappable GL/GR back buttons, amiibo, 3.5mm audio jack.
Nintendo Store product pages, read Nov 17, 2026; rumble and button notes from TheSixthAxis and Nintendo Life reviews (June 2025). Table: InStock Tracker.

Key Takeaways

  • GameCube controller: $69.99, and you need a paid Nintendo Switch Online membership to buy it.
  • Pro Controller: $89.99, no membership needed, sold by Nintendo and other retailers.
  • For The Wind Waker, F-Zero GX and the rest of the GameCube library, the GameCube pad feels like the real thing.
  • For Smash Ultimate, both work. The GameCube pad needs no remapping, per Nintendo Life.
  • For modern games, the Pro Controller wins: HD Rumble 2, GL/GR back buttons, amiibo and a headphone jack.

How we checked: we read both controllers' prices, stock and feature lists on the Nintendo Store on Nov 17, 2026. Rumble and missing-button notes come from TheSixthAxis's and Nintendo Life's June 2025 reviews of the GameCube controller.

How do the two controllers compare?

They're built for different jobs. The GameCube pad copies the original layout for old games. The Pro Controller is Nintendo's full-featured pad for Switch 2.

GameCube controllerSwitch 2 Pro Controller
Nintendo Store price$69.99$89.99
Stock, Nov 17In stockIn stock
To buy itPaid Nintendo Switch Online, limit 4No membership needed
Works onSwitch 2 onlySwitch 2 only
RumbleClassic rumble in some gamesHD Rumble 2
Motion controlsYesYes
Back buttonsNoGL and GR, remappable
Minus button, stick clicksNoYes
amiibo, audio jackNot listedYes, 3.5mm jack
Capture and C (GameChat) buttonsYesYes

Feature rows come from each Nintendo Store page. The rumble and button rows for the GameCube pad come from reviews, covered below.

Which is better for GameCube classics?

The GameCube controller. The Classics library was made for this shape: the big A button, the analog triggers and the C-stick. Nintendo Life's Ollie Reynolds called it "a WaveBird, but with rumble intact" (Nintendo Life, June 24, 2025).

Rumble is where it shines here. TheSixthAxis's review says classic rumble works in the GameCube library and Super Smash Bros. Ultimate (TheSixthAxis, June 23, 2025). It also has a small ZL button that opens the Classics menu quickly, per Nintendo Life.

You don't strictly need it. The GameCube controller page says it's "optional and not required" to play the library. A Pro Controller works there too. The library itself needs Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack, whichever pad you use.

One knock from Nintendo Life: the octagonal stick gates feel bumpy when you move the camera in The Wind Waker. If you grew up on the original, that's the authentic feel. If not, it may bother you.

Which is better for Smash Ultimate?

Either. Smash is the one modern game where the GameCube pad has no real downside.

Nintendo Life found it works well in Smash Ultimate with no remapping, and TheSixthAxis says rumble works there too. If you played Melee on a GameCube, the feel will come straight back.

The Pro Controller is the better all-round pick if Smash is one game among many. Its GL and GR back buttons can take any button you choose, and its HD Rumble 2 works across newer games too. Pick the GameCube pad if Smash is the main thing you play and you like that layout.

What does the GameCube controller lack?

Quite a lot for newer games. TheSixthAxis lists the gaps:

Nintendo Life adds that outside the Classics app, "functionality might be limited depending on the software." Inside the Classics, you can remap inputs from the Nintendo Switch Online menu. For a full rundown of where it works, see our guide to whether a GameCube controller works on Switch 2.

What does the Pro Controller lack?

The GameCube feel, and a lower price. It costs $20 more, and its standard layout doesn't match the old games' big A button and C-stick.

Nintendo's page lists HD Rumble 2, motion controls, built-in amiibo, a Capture button, a C button for GameChat, GL/GR back buttons "you can map to any button you choose," and a 3.5mm audio jack. For most Switch 2 games, nothing is missing. If you want a themed one, our Zelda Pro Controller guide compares the $99.99 Zelda edition.

Which one should you buy?

If you buy one controller, buy the Pro Controller. It plays everything, including the GameCube library, and you don't need a membership to buy it.

Add the GameCube controller if you pay for Expansion Pack and play the GameCube library or Smash often. Both were in stock on Nov 17. Nintendo labels the GameCube pad a store exclusive, so one shop's stock is all there is. Check live controller stock before you buy, or set a free restock alert if one sells out.

Frequently asked questions

Is the GameCube controller better than the Pro Controller for Smash?

Neither is clearly better. The GameCube pad works in Smash Ultimate with no remapping and with rumble, per Nintendo Life and TheSixthAxis. The Pro Controller adds remappable GL and GR back buttons and HD Rumble 2. Pick the layout your hands already know.

Can you use a Pro Controller for GameCube Nintendo Classics?

Yes. Nintendo's GameCube controller page says that controller is "optional and not required" for the GameCube Nintendo Classics library. Any Switch 2 controller works there. You still need a Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack membership to play the library, whichever controller you hold.

Why is the GameCube controller $20 cheaper than the Pro Controller?

It does less. Nintendo's store pages list HD Rumble 2, amiibo, GL/GR back buttons and an audio jack on the $89.99 Pro Controller. The $69.99 GameCube pad has none of those listed, and reviewers note it lacks a minus button, stick clicks and HD Rumble support.

Do you need Nintendo Switch Online to buy the GameCube controller?

Yes. Nintendo's store page says you need a paid Nintendo Switch Online membership to buy it, free trials don't qualify, and each account can buy four. The Pro Controller has no such rule. You can buy it without any membership from Nintendo or other retailers.

Sources